Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

JustHere | December 6, 2016

Scroll to top

Back to Top

3 Comments

[OPINION] Israel’s Shahar Peer to play in Qatar again; Should sports be exempted from sanctions?

Shabeb Al Rumaihi

The Israeli debate is a hot one in the region. At so many levels – cultural, ethnic, religious and humanitarian – people take strong stance on the kind of relationship the Arab world should have with Israel.

There are strong voices for and against normalisation. There have been multiple movements on social media in the past two years against Israeli-representations in different spheres in Qatar. The last one was the FINA swimming world cup at Aspire in late October of 2013. The Israeli flag was raised at the Hamad Aquatic Center and it triggered severe criticism, leading to the removal of the flag. The Israeli team continued its participation.

peer-insideNext week the Qatar Total Open women’s tennis tournament will be held. And the list on Qatar Tennis Federation (QTF) website shows Israeli player Shahar Peer (ranked 86 in the world). This is the fourth time that Shahar comes to Qatar. The very first campaign of Qatar Youth Opposed to Normalization (QAYON) was related to her participation last year.

I would assume that many of you would argue against boycotting Israel? Or that sports and politics should not be mixed?  Well it’s not just a boycott, it’s a resistance movement against any form of racial discrimination. Not just as Muslims or Arabs, but as human beings, we cannot ignore the fact that Israeli players get the opportunity to come and go as they please while Palestinians are denied the right to return to their homeland. How is it possible to allow representatives from an apartheid state to play in sports while it oppresses Palestinians not just politically but culturally as well?

QAYON, a content-driven activist group, believes that since Israel mixes sports with politics, there has to be reciprocal action. Sports after all has been a political tool, take for example the ping-pong diplomacy between the US and China.

Yesterday, the group published a letter (in Arabic) that was addressed to Head of QTF Saad Bin Saleh Al-Mohannadi requesting that Shahar Peer not be allowed to participate in the tournament. The letter mentions Qataris support of Palestinians during the Nakba, and said while the federation worked hard on being recognised internationally, it also had to take a stand and tell the world that sports is an exercise that believes in equal opportunities and universality between all participants.

If we allow for normalisation between the Arab world and Israel then we must expect a change in the latter’s policies as well. What about Palestinian footballer Mahmoud Sarsak, who was arrested in 2009 and held for three years without a fair trials?

That same year Ayman Alkurd, Shade Sbakhe and Wajeh Moshtahe, three Palestinian footballers, were murdered in Gaza.

Palestinian footballers have been repeatedly denied the exit visas to participate in AFC tournaments: in 2006, 2007 and 2010.

In 2006 Israel bombed a stadium in Gaza. It was rebuilt with the help of FIFA but was bombed again in 2012.

Sports is about “fair match”, it seems quite irrational not just for Qatar Tennis Federation, but any sporting federation to not take that into cognizance.

 

Editor’s Note: Shahar Peer did not make it to the final draw as her ranking was low, and will not be appearing in this year’s tournament.

Copyright © 2013 JustHere Qatar. Reproduction of material from any JustHere Qatar pages without written permission is strictly prohibited.

Comments

  1. Andy

    One thing you forget is that the tournament is sanctiond by WTA! QTA dont make the rules! If they dont want to accept WTA rules then the tournament wont be held in Qatar. Now its a matter of choice, and the choice to host these events are for?

  2. Suad

    Dear Andy,
    Most people would argue the same about applying the WTA rules and mixing sports with politics in the case of the tournament but then lets not avoid the main issue here and the writer’s actual point “act rather than turn a blind eye on Israeli’s human rights abuse against Palestinians”. Boycotting Israel in this case i think is basically taking into practice the power they have in hosting the tournament to act as a human rights watch in the region against discriminatory acts by Israel which is a good thing although i don’t know if practical. Which bring me to the matter of you said choice? in regards to hosting the tournament its more of an obligation to accept the rules of the WTA which Qatar is doing but at the same time making it clear where they stand when it comes to human rights which intersects into politics in sports in this case.

  3. Tom

    What I find intellectually dishonest is the fact that you evidently have no problem with athletes from truly repressive and barbaric nations participating. Moreover, while you criticze Isreal for hitting gaza you conveniently leave out the fact that this is in response to repeated rocket attacks. While Isreal withdrew from gaza the groups have continued to fire rockets into Isreal. What did you expect them to do – not fire back? If gaza attacks Isreal then you cannot blame Isreal for hitting back.

Submit a Comment


*

jhiuhiuiui